Sons and Lovers is an
autobiographical novel published by D. H. Lawrence, one of the most well-known
authors of the Modern Era. A male child's attraction to his mother is referred
to as the "Oedipal complex" by Sigmund Freud in his theory of
psychosexual phases of development. The Oedipus complex, according to Freud,
was crucial to the phallic stage of psychosexual development.
The term Oedipus has
been derived from the name of the King Oedipus of Thebes, who, though in
ignorance, married his own mother and had children by her. Freud used this term
to explain the manifestation of infantile sexuality in the relation of the
child to its parents. The Oedipus complex “is
a state which a person shows excessive affection for the parent opposite in sex
to him or herself, and a corresponding distaste for his or her other parent.” If
it is a son who is excessively fond of his mother as is Paul Morel fond of Mrs.
Morel and extends his fondness beyond puberty, adversely affecting the harmony
of his relationship with other girls, we may also describe him as a victim of
the mother fixation.
It is well acknowledged
that D.H. Lawrence suffered from a severe Oedipus complex. He was very much
influenced by his mother Lydia Lawrence, and he also thought of her as a lover.
She was the one who gave him warmth to live. The inspiration she provided him
also determined his outlook on life and literature. When Mrs. Lawrence was
practically on her deathbed in 1910, Lawrence urged his publisher to publish
The White Peacock quickly so that his mother may read it while she was still
conscious. In many of his early poetry, he also frequently expresses how much
they loved one another like young lovers.
Disillusioned with her
husband Walter Morel, Mrs. Morel gradually casts him off and takes her two sons
William and Paul as husband’s substitutes one after the other, thus wrecking
their emotional life. Gertrude Morel, a fantastically moral and religious
woman, at twenty-one, marries a warm, sensuous and indulgent miner, Walter
Morel. The couple's first few months of marriage are filled with joy, but over
time, the close connection created by their poetized passion breaks, and Mrs.
Morel becomes dissatisfied by her husband's regular drinking, his indulgent and
slothful behaviour, and his temperamental dishonesty. As her oldest son William
gets older, Mrs. Morel starts to distance herself from her husband and turns to
her son for emotional gratification. William also reacts to her on instinct. Once,
when he is seven, he brings for her, from the fair, two egg-cups with moss
roses on them and presents them to her almost like a lover. When he brings home
the first prize he has won at school, she receives it almost like a queen. But
she is so over-possessive that as William comes in contact with other girls and
goes dancing with them, she finds it difficult to tolerate them. In fact she
expresses her hostility towards them in rather crude and jarring terms. Later,
when William falls in love with a passionate girl called Gyp and brings her
home on a short visit, she is vehemently critical of her. Under her influence,
Williams finds it difficult to strike a balance between his love for his mother
and his infatuation for Gyp, he suffers from terrible spiritual anguish and
finally dies.
After the early
infantile psycho-sexual development, according to Freud, the Oedipus complex
goes dormant for a few years until becoming active again at puberty. In the
case of Paul, the early migration to London of William makes him closer to his
mother, though it is finally recognised only when Paul is down with severe attack
of pneumonia after William’s death. Mrs. Morel tightens her hold on his soul
while they sleep together as she tries desperately to save him from succumbing
to death. Paul "realises" his mother during this illness, and he is
also precisely at puberty at the time. The Oedipus complex is bound to entail
the envy of the father. Unconsciously, the youngster perceives his father as a
rival for the affection of his mother. As a result, there is animosity and
antagonism between the father and the son. Paul despises his father a lot. He
once feels that it would be simpler to forgo the reward than to beg his father
for approval when Mrs. Morel asks him to show his father the trophy he has won.
Even his father's gaze is intolerable to Paul, who scornfully rejects all of
his efforts to be kind to him. Mrs. Morel's obsession with Paul causes her
husband to feel a great deal of jealousy as well as some hazy suspicions of
incest. In Chapter VIII, there is a very significant episode that brings into
focus the entire conflict. Mrs. Morel expresses her jealousy of Miriam and
suddenly says, “And I’ve never-you know,
Paul I’ve never had a husband, not really” Paul strokes his mother’s hair
and his mouth is on her throat. And she kisses him a long, fervent kiss, which
is followed by a gentle stroking of her face by Paul. Just then enters Mr.
Morel and standing in the doorway, venomously remarks, “At your mischief again?”
Paul tries to play the
part of Mrs. Morels' husband because she admits in the story that she never had
one in the true sense. Paul has assumed the position of the head of the
household over the most of the second half of the book. His relation with his
mother is that of a husband substitute. He acts as though he were her man and
stayed with her out of instinct. On
their visit to Nottingham he chatted away with his mother and she was gay like
a sweetheart. Later “they walked down the
station street, feeling the excitement of lovers having an adventure together;
they arrived home in the mellow evening, happy and glowing, and tired.”
During a visit to Mrs. Leiver’s Farm “they
went out into the wood that was flooded with bluebells.........the
bluebells........the mother and the son were in ecstasy together.” The
flowers which Paul sticks in her coat offer another concrete symbol of this
love. But perhaps one of the clearest examples is found in Paul’s regretful
raving at having an ‘old’ mother for a sweetheart: “Why can’t a man have a young mother? What is the old for? “Well,” his
mother laughed, “she can scarcely help it.” “And why wasn’t I the oldest son?
Look they say the young ones have the advantage—but look, they had the young
mother. You should have had me for your oldest son.”
Paul fails to establish
harmonious relationships with both Clara and Miriam. These mistakes weren't
entirely Paul's fault; there is some blame to be shared with his mother. Paul
is an artist, and most artists are romantic and kind-hearted. Paul is seduced
by Clara's passionate and untamed character, but only for a short while. In
life, excess of anything should be avoided, and Paul follows this rule. Clara
is the embodiment of passion and wild love, whereas Paul is tender and can't
hold Clara for very long. As a result, he begins to avoid her. On the other
side, Miriam is equal to Paul, but he never sees her as a replacement for his
mother. He desires a beloved, and in her, he desires the nurturing qualities of
a mother. But there is another aspect of it also. In Chapter XIII, Paul tells
his mother that he loved Clara deeply. He had loved Miriam also. But at the
same time could not possibly marry them. “You
haven’t met the right woman.” “And I never shall meet the right woman while you
live,” he said.
Both spiritually and
physically Paul is glued to his mother. Paul must always be seeking for
mother-image in his woman. Paul gets dissatisfied both with Miriam and Clara,
he clings on to his mother. Their inter-dependence on each other never
declines. He breaks off both with Miriam and Clara. In fact, life for him is
only where his mother is and when she dies, he becomes indifferent to life and
death alike.
The bond between the
sons and the mother is the direct outcome of Oedipus complex. Both William and
Paul hate their father and Paul even pray to the God that his father should
die. When William is born, Walter the husband becomes an outsider as he is not
given love, care, affection and attention. The sons treat their father as their
enemy. In the Greek mythology, Oedipus commits the sin of killing his own
father and marrying his own biological mother unconsciously and under a curse
but the suffering of Walter at the hands of his sons and his wife Gertrude is
done deliberately and intentionally. In the modern age, whatever we do
knowingly or unknowingly it is the psychological dilemma set by modern
psychologists on the basis of their observations and studies. The suffering of
Paul and Mrs. Morel is no less than the suffering of Oedipus and Jocasta.
William and Paul are not able to form intimate bond with their beloved. They
are not able to form union with their souls and they keep on dangling between
their mother and their beloved. It is this Oedipus complex that forbids Paul to
think about any other woman to be his life partner. He is like Hamlet divided
between head and heart. The head says don’t ditch the mother and the heart says
Miriam is a nice woman to live with. But he keeps on struggling on the point
that he is unable to find the mother substitute in Miriam. The true and real
solace can be found only in the mother and this is why it seems as if the naval
string is still attached. Paul cannot find his personality away from his
mother. He dies every second in his life when it is revealed that Mrs. Morel is
suffering from cancer. The love was so much so that he gives the overdose of
morpheme to his mother to set her free from the pain. The bond was so strong that
even after the death of his mother, he chooses to live alone and he leaves
Miriam forever. Though the mother was not alive but she is always there in his
mind saying that no woman is right for him.
Sons and Lovers has
been described as the first Freudian novel in English As Sons and Lovers is an
autobiographical novel, we find that D.H. Lawrence has given a true and real
account of his life and how he felt and experienced in the company of his
mother.